REVISION
Academic style, please use Oscola.
I need a professional writer with background in Law, especially knowledge in International Human right. This Paper assignment is (40% of final grade) deadline submission: 29 September 2021,
There will be a plagiarism check, the consequence is jail time, so please do not plagiarize someone else work.
The notion of universality is one of the key principles of international human rights law. It is also a very much contested principle. In this paper you are to discuss the principle of universality and the ongoing controversy.
Illustrate your discussion with reference to at least one' reservation' to one of the nine core human rights treaties. Since my topic is on capital punishment, I will suggest that you use the ICCPR treaty to illustrate the universality principle and ongoing controversy. The USA made a reservation regarding the dead penalties under the ICCPR, you must explore how the treaty body (or bodies) selected, approaches the(se) reservation(s).
The selected reservation must regards the substance of human rights, not a procedural reservation.
Do not forget to explain relevant concepts, such as the universality principle and treaty reservations. The paper must be new and original:
This assignment leaves considerable freedom regarding the contents of the paper. You are thus required to formulate own research question, and you are expected to provide a clear conclusion on the findings you present in the main section of the paper.
Regardless of the focus and structure that you choose, the paper should demonstrate (as a minimum) a clear understanding of the universality principle and the legal area of reservations, and of the material covered in weeks 1 4 of this course (of course only in so far as the material is relevant to the topic). For example
The paper should include the following elements:
A discussion of the universality principle (so: a demonstrable understanding of that principle) and how it fits into the wider international human rights system;
A discussion of how and why various actors (e.g. states, treaty bodies, courts, etc.) may have different views on the issue;
An analysis of (a) point(s) of contention surrounding the principle in light of academic literature;
An appreciation of relevant context and legal aspects related to the principle of universality;
A clear conclusion that explicitly addresses your independently formulated research question.
Length: Approximately no more than 2.500, excluding footnotes and references.
The quality of the argumentation will count for more than the writing style.) Use page numbers.
List of all sources used (bibliography): distinguish between literature (incl. authoritative human rights reports etc.), legal documents, and other sources (e.g. websites, newspaper articles). Make sure the information is complete and offered in a systematic, consistent way. Structure: explain the structure chosen in the introduction; avoid to lengthy paragraphs by using sub-headings.
Method: make the central focus/research question clear in the introduction, and explain how the analysis is tackled. You are expected to use the (relevant) material prescribed for the first four weeks of the course.
You are strongly encouraged to use also other material, however only in addition to the material prescribed, not instead of that material.
Quote as little as possible. If you feel you must quote, make the quote clear by putting the text between inverted commas () and mention the source (including page number or paragraphs number) in a footnote. Read the information on plagiarism carefully: it has very serious consequences. Non-compliance with any of these practical requirements will be reflected in the grade!
MATERIALS
– please, rely heavily on human rights instruments and General comments (GC)
WEEK 1
* Shelton chapters 1 + 2.
CASELAW: ECtHR, GC, Mamatkulov & Askarov v. Turkey (Appl.nos. 46827/99 and 46951/99), 4 February 2005 can be downloaded from the Courts database (HUDOC; accessible via the Courts home page: 2 https://echr.coe.int/Pages/home.aspx?p=home). You do not need to study the case in great detail; focus on the main issues (see also the working group questions below)..
WEEK 2
Shelton, chapters 3 and 4
CASELAW – ECtHR [GC], S.A.S. v. France, (appl. no. 43835/11), 1 July 2014 – HRC Decision, Sonia Yaker v France, 7 December 2018, CCPR/C/123/D/2747/2016
– Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR)
– International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) – Human Rights Committee,
General Comment No. 24 on reservations, 4 November 1994, CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.6
WEEK 3
Julie Fraser, Social institutions and international human rights law implementation: Every organ of society, CUP, 2020 [available as an e-book in the university library].
CASELAW:- Sandra Lovelace v. Canada, Communication No. R.6/24, UN Doc, Supp. No. 40 (A/36/40) at 166, 30 July 1981 [posted on blackboard] 2 – Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Aloeboetoe et al v. Suriname, summary of judgments delivered on 4 December 1991 and 10 September 1993 [summary posted on blackboard]. [For those students who wish to read the full judgment the decision on the merits can be found at: http://www.corteidh.or.cr/docs/casos/articulos/seriec_11_ing.pdf;
the decision on costs and reparations can be found at: http://www.corteidh.or.cr/docs/casos/articulos/seriec_15_ing.pdf.] – CEDAW Committee, General Recommendation no. 21 on Equality in marriage and family relations, adopted during the thirteenth session 1994, UN Doc. A/49/38 [posted on blackboard]. – Human Rights Committee,
General Comment no. 28 on Equality of rights between men and women (article 3), 29/03/2000, CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.10 [posted on blackboard].
– CESCR, General Comment no. 16, Article 3: the equal right of men and women to the enjoyment of all economic, social and cultural rights, 13 May 2005, E/C.12/2005/3
WEEK 4
Shelton chapter 6 Legally binding instrument to regulate, in international human rights law, the activities of transnational corporations and other business enterprises; OEIGWG chairmanship, third revised draft, 17.08.2021 Nadia Bernaz, Conceptualizing Corporate Accountability in International Law: Models for a Business and Human Rights Treaty, Human Rights Review (2021) 22:4564
.
There are 9 core international human rights instruments. Each of these instruments has established a committee of experts to monitor implementation of the treaty provisions by its States parties. Some of the treaties are supplemented by optional protocols dealing with specific concerns whereas the Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture establishes a committee of experts. you can find these instrument
at (https://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/coreinstruments.aspx).
– You should also rely on other human rights regional bodies and their caselaw to draw distinctions and argument and to demonstrate knowledge in human right instrument in regards to the principle of universality and its controversy. '
for example regional human right bodies such as:
– The European convention of human rights (ECHR) https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/convention_eng.pdf
-The American convention. which you find through this link
https://www.oas.org/dil/access_to_information_American_Convention_on_Human_Rights.pdf
-The African charter on human and people's right, https://www.achpr.org/legalinstruments/detail?id=49)
RELEVANT GENERAL COMMENTS
Please consult this book below, for additional information.
Dinah Shelton, Advanced introduction to international human rights law, Edward Elgar, 2020 (2nd revised edition)
An e-book version is available via this link:
(Advanced Introduction to International Human Rights Law (advancedintros.com).
Also consult article Julie Fraser (2020), Chapter 2: Human Rights and Their Cultural Connection…. ''i will upload this article in the material.
For example if you choose to write on this topic in the light of (equality & universality)
I. READING should be on Chapter 5: of the book i noted in this information (((Dinah Shelton, Advanced introduction to international human rights law, Edward Elgar, 2020 (2nd revised edition)
emphasis on the prohibition of discrimination in Art. 1(3), 55(c) UNCH, Art. 1, 2(1), 7 UDHR inter alia
– requirements of equality and non-discrimination at the center of hr law
1 The scope of the requirement of non-discrimination
– two categories of non-discrimination provisions: (1) dependent on other substantive provisions & (2) independent application of non-discrimination clause in all fields: Art. 26 ICCPR
– Art. 14 ECHR: limited to the enjoyment of the rights and freedoms of the ECHR and its Protocols
– = not independent, but autonomous: doesnt presuppose breach of other right in the ECHR
– Art. E Europe. Social Charter: no discrimination in enjoyment of other substantive rights of Charter
(mirroring Art. 14 ECHR)
– Art. 1(1) American Convention on Human Rights (ACHR): see Art. 26 ICCPR (independent)
2 The range of States obligations
– Art. 26 ICCPR implicitly contains four separate norms, imposing on States the obligation to
1) guarantee equality before the law
– addressed to law enforcement authorities (executive, judiciary)
2) guarantee the equal protection of the law
– addressed at lawmaker: law must not create discrimination, neither direct nor indirect
3) prohibit any discrimination, and
– positive obligation on the legislator to prohibit and sanction
– main difficulty: scope (not in private interactions concerning private sphere)
4) guarantee to all persons equal and effective protection against discrimination
– this may include the adoption of positive action measures against structural discrimination
– a difference of treatment is discriminatory if it has no objective and reasonable justification
– legitimate aim and reasonable relationship of proportionality between means and aim
– difficult to discriminate people due to their nationality when they are permanent residents
– e.g. disabilities: even a law applied in a neutral manner may have a discriminatory effect if it the circumstances of the individual to whom it is applied are not taken into consideration
– suspect grounds for differential treatment require particularly strong justifications by States (e.g. nationality, health)
3 The notion of discrimination
– direct discrimination:
= open differentiation on the basis of a ground which lacks reasonable and objective justification
– indirect discrimination/de facto discrimination:
= use of neutral criteria, the effect of which will be similar to that of direct discrimination
– intention is irrelevant
– can depend on use of statistics (US Supreme Court, Griggs v. Duke power Co. 1971)
– also: when States fail to treat people differently whose situations are different
I will include this article in the uploaded material section Julie Fraser (2020), Chapter 2: Human Rights and Their Cultural Connection
This article helps you to understand the universality principle and applying it to the research paper. Below is a summary i made from reading the article.
– universal hr apply to everyone, based on the inherent dignity of being human
– universality is challenged based on different cultures, religions, etc.
– accusations of cultural relativism; postcolonial critiques challenge Western influence
– disconnect between culture & human rights contributes to their poor implementation in practice
– relationship between culture & hr is misunderstood; culture is seen as obstacle to hr
– central element of culturally sensitive approaches to hr: focus on social institutions for implementation
2.2 Human Rights and Their History of Cultural Critiques
– UDHR founded our system of hr, but doesnt name one single source of human rights or dignity
– critique of creation of UDHR: democratic deficit; many African and Asian states didnt participate
– but others argue that non-Wester instead of Western governments were the strong supporters
– of the 18 UN HRC members negotiating it, 9 were non-Western (but partly educated in the West)
– overall, no single sub-Saharan representative -> largely reflective of Western culture
– cultural relativists: validity of a cultural norm can only be determined in that cultural framework, not externally
– any universalism oppresses some populations
– one scholarly approach is to show the foundations of human rights in non-Western history/culture
– the debate centers around whether hr are universal in nature and application or culturally relative
– part of hr bias is focus on individual over community, on civil and political rights over EXC rights, emphasis on rights over duties
– a) Asian values debate: 1993 Bangkok Declaration, 2012 ASEAN HR Declaration
– b) TWAIL and postcolonial scholars: white saviourism; hr part of legitimation of Western intervention
– consequences: abandon or reform/reconceptualize
– c) based on Islam: central issue is priority of divine law (e.g. 1990 Cairo Declaration on HR in Islam)
– only two, but serious conflicts of Islam with hr: womens rights and freedom of religion
– critics contest conception, content & application of human rights
– now: consensus on a set of core human rights; come space for legitimate cultural variations
– culturally sensitive universalism (Engle)
– influence of newly independent States on hr: right to self-determination mentioned in the two Covenants (1966), but not (yet) in the UDHR (1948)
– first hr treaty: Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (1965)
– end of colonialism did not necessarily conclude the end of colonial relations
– end of Cold War -> 1993 World Conference on HR with Vienna Declaration
– UDHR influences regional developments (e.g. Asian, African, Arab Charters reference UDHR)
– hr regime still evolving: e.g. Conventions on Forced Disappearance & Persons w/ Disabilities (2006)
– hr law is young: experimental status instead of final truth
– culture as a process, combining stability with persistent dynamism
– problematic perception of culture in int. law as static, monolithic, homogenous, even primitive
– while int. law and human rights are perceived as modern culture-free zones
-> increasing recognition of cultural dimension of hr
-> and a culturally appropriate implementation of hr
2.3 Culturally Sensitive Approaches to Human Rights Implementation
– need for human rights for better recognition and accommodation of cultural diversity
– universality =/= uniform implementation
– both from a normative (value of diversity) and a practical perspective (legitimacy and efficacy)
– 1) stress need for cultural sensitivity
– important to develop substantive meaning (nature & content) of hr in local contexts
– decentred approach: make hr less theoretical and aspirational and more real and practical
– focus on implementation
– 2) promote non-legislative measures to implement hr instead of state law
– ineffectiveness of culturally insensitive laws
– acknowledge non-state normative orders like cultural traditions, customary law, religious law, womens associations, traditional medicine, etc. with strong legitimacy
– informal systems like culturally based non-state dispute resolution mechanisms as opportunity
– Zwarts receptor approach uses these receptor as gateway to rights-holders
– smart mix of these measures supplementing/complementing state law
– 3) promote home-grown solutions for hr problems
– also: bottom-up approaches: users /actor-oriented perspective
– realization of rights through local practice
– community-based reform if necessary -> local ownership
– e.g. use virginity testing in South Africa as means to inform about sexual and reproductive health
– vernacularisation, translation: process of appropriation and local adoption of globally generated ideas and strategies
– but: risk of distorting and diluting rights, or to blend in too much to change anything really
– problem: different cultures in one single state
– 4) rely on cultures dynamism and contestation to further hr compliance
– hr can be influential or even instrumental in the change of dynamic, contested cultural norms
– promote intra-cultural dialogue to employ coexisting alternatives in line with hr within a culture
– examine actual practices within a culture instead of just normative pronouncements
– participation and input from variety of actors to shape culture based on their agency
– central question of who within a culture gets to influence, interpret and determine a culture
– inclusivity of disadvantaged groups may already challenge cultural norms (e.g. women)
– external actors play a role, but should be measured, as they can be ineffective or even counter-productive
– cross-cultural dialogue
2.3.5 Effectiveness of Culturally Sensitive Approaches to Implementation
– problems:
– 1) relying on cultures dynamism to reform local norms can be time consuming and uncertain & involves delay or failure to protect rights in the interim
-> this is more suitable to rights subject to progressive realization, and shouldnt be the only measure that is relied upon
– state should stay involved and provide safety-net; e.g. for women to opt-out of their cultural system and find remedies
– 2) the risk of determination/codification of cultural norms by states, rendering them static
Human Right COMMUNICATION, General Comment 24 (1994): Issues Relating to Reservations to the ICCPR or its OPs
– reservations relating to particular rights, more general terms, or competence of the Committee
– form of the instrument (reservation, declaration, etc.) is not important, but the intention
– para. 3: statement that purports to exclude or modify the legal effect of a treaty
– ICCPR neither prohibits not permits any type of reservation -> recourse to int. law
– Art. 19(3) VCLT: where reservations are not expressly prohibited, they are allowed if compatible with object and purpose of the treaty
– para. 8: reservations offending peremptory norms & customary law are incompatible with ICCPR
– para. 9,10: incompatible: art. 1, art. 2(1) & 2(2), art. 4 (non-derogable even in times of emergency)
– para. 11: incompatible: art. 2(3) & to the monitoring & interpreting function of the Committee
– para. 12: of particular concern are widely formulated reservations to avoid changing nat. law, remedies before domestic courts, or individual complaints under OP1
– para. 13: incompatible: reservations to the OP1
– para. 16: an objection against a reservation leads to the invalidity of the reservation btw. those two states
– para. 17: VCLT inappropriate for hr treaties (due to lack of reciprocity)
-> lack of objections (no legal interest) -> unclear pattern, no compatibility-control
– effect of objections in hr treaties is questionable, only guidance for the Committee
– para. 18: legal authority to determine compatibility of falls to the Committee
(partly because inappropriate task for states, partly because of a functionalistic approach)
– para. 18: severability-doctrine: treaty is in effect for reserving party, but reservation is invalid
– para. 19: reservations must be specific and transparent; limited to a particular provision
– para. 20: states should, i.a., periodically review their reservations & withdraw them asap
HRCOM, Sandra Lovelace v. Canada (1981), Communication
– facts:
– Sandra Lovelace, Maliseet Indian living in New Brunswick, married non-Indian man
– in accordance with section 12(I)(b) of the Indian Act she lost her Indian status & rights
– no similar loss of status accorded to an Indian man marrying non-Indian woman
– Lovelace alleged that this provision of the Indian act is discriminatory on the grounds of sex
– contrary to art. 2(1), 3, 23(1) and (4), 26 and 27 ICCPR
– admissible (exhaustion of local remedies not required in this case)
– para. 5: Indian act as instrument to protect a minority according to art. 27 ICCPR
(right to occupy reserve lands; patrilineal relationships determine land ownership)
– Lovelace argues that the Committee should require Canada to amend the provisions
– the loss of Indian status occurred before Canada had ratified the ICCPR
– but Committee finds breach of art. 27 ICCPR (right to live in the reserve)
Tips on Reservation
– Art. 2(1)(d) VCLT: definition of reservation
– unilateral
– name doesnt matter, intention is central (exclude or modify legal effect)
– Art. 19 VCLT: conditions excluding reservations, esp. (c): incompatible with object & purpose
– Art. 20: acceptance and objections by other state parties
-> problematic lack of reciprocal legal interest in hr law
-> very few objections by other states & legal effect
– Art. 21 VCLT: legal effects of reservations
-> in general int. law, ratification is null and void; meaningless in hr law
-> according to hr law, the reservation will be severed and void, but treaty still valid
Example of finding a reservation,
– India reserved art. 1 ICCPR (self-determination) -> reservation or declaration?
– Mexico reserved art. 25b: secular tradition
– USA reserved ICCPR: capital punishment for minors -> Committee said it was incompatible
– Oman, CEDAW: All provisions not in accordance with the Islamic sharia and legislation in force in the Sultanate of Oman
– not acceptable
– general (all provisions), not specific enough
– sharia: very far-reaching!
– will not be acceptable
– in light of religious differences: no
– certain differences in implementation are ok, but not generally excluding force
– unclear legal situation; better not to ratify the treaty then
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
