What do you think this tells us about the intrinsic value of being healthy?

After reading Faring Well and Getting What You Want by Chris Heathwood, respond to the following questions concerning cultural relativism and subjectivism located at the end of the chapter. Your response to each question should be 100 words in length.

Heathwood claims that the meaningfulness of a life can vary independently from how well off the person living it is. To see whether you agree, try to describe an example of (a) a life that you think is meaningful that is not beneficial to the person living it, and (b) a life that is beneficial to the person living it without being a meaningful life.
Suppose someone claims that being healthy is intrinsically good for us. Can you think of a way to test whether this is true? Here is one idea: describe a pair of cases that are exactly alike except that in one of the cases, the person involved has greater health than in the other case. Its crucial that there be no other differences between the cases. What do you think this tells us about the intrinsic value of being healthy?
Do you agree that Charlies gains in freedom turned out to be of no benefit to him? If they are of no benefit to him, is that enough to show that objectivism about well-being is mistaken? If not, what more is required?
What is an ideal desire as opposed to an actual desire? Which kind of desire does Heathwood think is connected to welfare? Why does he think this?
Do you believe that Heathwood benefits when, unbeknownst to him, his exiled uncle achieves happiness and health? Why or why not?
According to one version of the desire theory of welfare, a person is benefited just when a desire that is about her own life is satisfied. Is this theory plausible? Explain.
Heathwood thinks that our life is a good life for us to the extent that we get what we want, so long as we are aware of it, and so long as this is a want in the genuine attraction sense of want. Are there any cases in which your life goes better for you even though no such want is satisfied? Are there any cases in which such wants are satisfied, but one fails to be benefited as a result?

Last Completed Projects