What are some of the benefits and/or challenges when providing an explanation of evil in the context of a logical system?

In the lists below, Group 1 represents the authors we have read who, broadly speaking, offer an account of evil that is synthesized into a larger logical/ontological system and/or theodicy argument. Group 2 is a diverse set of thinkers, but broadly speaking each of their arguments challenge the validity of theodicy as a viable explanation for evil and deny the compatibility of evil with a larger logical/ontological system. Choose one thinker from each group and respond to the below questions.

Group 1: Leibniz, Plantinga, Berkovits

Group 2: Mackie, Dostoevsky (consider both Ivan and Zossima), Rubenstein, Arendt & Butler

Who do you think has asserted a more compelling and comprehensive argument responding to the problem of evil and why? What are some of the benefits and/or challenges when providing an explanation of evil in the context of a logical system? Consider both moral and epistemological implications in your discussion.

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered