Should books we don’t like be banned???

This weeks discussion is based on an unusual circumstance. One of the textbooks we use in our Chicano Studies course here at Butte College is Occupied America: A History of Chicanos by Rodolfo Acuna. It is also used at Chico State University. Professor Acuna is one of the most widely renowned scholars of Chicano Studies and is a professor emeritus of Chicano Studies at California State University at Northridge (Rodolfo Acuna)(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rodolfo_Acu%C3%B1a). I have used his book for years as a reference.

Recently a bill was passed in Arizona that may result in having the textbook banned.

http://articles.latimes.com/2010/may/12/nation/la-na-ethnic-studies-20100512

HB 2281 bans schools from teaching classes that are designed for students of a particular ethnic group, promote resentment or advocate ethnic solidarity over treating pupils as individuals. The bill also bans classes that promote the overthrow of the U.S. government.

When the bill was proposed, an article from the East Valley Tribune a newspaper that serves the suburbs of Phoenix Arizona stated, Another section of the bill would bar public schools, community colleges and universities from allowing organizations to operate on campus if it is “based in whole or in part on race-based criteria,” a provision Rep. Russell Pearce, R-Mesa, said is aimed at MEChA, the Moviemiento Estudiantil Chicano de Aztlan, a student group. The implications are that many other student organizations would also, under this bill, be banned.

According to the author of the bill Rep. Russell Pearce, SB1108 (The bill’s title before passage) would also bar teaching practices that “overtly encourage dissent from American values”

http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2008/04/17/20080417unamerican0417.html?source=nletter-news
Moreover, The Wall Street Journal has reported that the Arizona Department of Education recently began to direct school districts to remove teachers whose spoken English is deemed to be heavily accented or ungrammatical.

According to the article, In the 1990s, Arizona hired hundreds of teachers whose first language was Spanish as part of a broad bilingual-education program. Many were recruited from Latin America. Then in 2000, voters passed a ballot measure stipulating that instruction be offered only in English. Bilingual teachers who had been instructing in Spanish switched to English.

Thus, it appears that hundreds of Latino teachers will be under attack to be fired.

Here is the Wall Street Journal article:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703572504575213883276427528.html

Here is an interesting segment from Democracy Now where its host Amy Goodman interviews Professor Acuna and a recently fired high school teacher, Karen Salazar, who teaches in Los Angeles for teaching an Afrocentric view (I believe she used some material from Malcolm X and Langston Hughes in her classroom). This is the same video above in case it does not open here.

LA School Teacher Fired for Being Too “Afrocentric”

Here is Professor Acunas written response.

Scholar, Activist Rudy Acuna Responds to Arizona’s “Big Lie” Law, SB 1108

Here is the twist Id like to throw your way for discussion. In law school, our professors would often force students to make the opposite, more difficult argument.

Soif you canMake the argument that the Arizona Law HB2281 is a good thing and should be enacted here in California as good public policy.

Be careful. This is an assignment where my students sometimes forget the instructions and “lose it” with student comments. It’s a very difficult set of instructions. In the end, relax… and have a good sense of humor. The interesting thing you will discover is that the very same arguments you make (even if you don’t personally agree with them) are arguments that are seriously maintained by many Americans.

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered