Is it morally permissible (or even obligatory) for Canadian private businesses to give special consideration to Indigenous applicants during the hiring process?

The goal of this assignment is for you to provide a thoughtful argument for a claim about ethical business conduct. While you should consider both sides of the debate, you need to ultimately settle on a clear answer to the essay question. The focus of your essay should be primarily on moral, rather than legal, issues.

The subject of your essay must be the following question:

Is it morally permissible (or even obligatory) for Canadian private businesses to give special consideration to Indigenous applicants during the hiring process? If no, why not? If yes, what should such a programme look like?

: Your essay must be between 1200 and 1500 words in length (not counting the ‘sources-cited’ section). Your essay should begin with a very short introduction that clearly states your thesis/answer to the essay question (as a rule of thumb, this should be less than 60 words), and provides a roadmap of the main body of the essay (as a rule of thumb, the whole introduction should be less than 150 words). You should provide a short conclusion at the end of your essay that, again, states your thesis and your main argument for it (as a rule of thumb, the conclusion should be less than 140 words). In the main body of your essay you need to argue for your position by providing reasons and responding to obvious objections. Throughout the essay, you should make use of the course readings.

Citations: Avoid direct quotations. Summarizing and paraphrasing are best. You should rely mainly on the course readings, and the in-class materials. You may cite outside sources or the lecture slides, but neither is recommended.

Course readings should be cited using APA format by giving the author’s name, the publication year, and a page number. For example, you might write:

According to Goldman, affirmative action programs tend to benefit individuals who have not suffered significant discrimination (Goldman, 1975, p. 169).

To cite a lecture, you might write:

As discussed in class (Lecture 8, slide 24), technology is ubiquitous in today’s corporate world

Sources Cited Section: At the end of your essay you need to list the sources you have cited. Please use the APA format. For example, your list might look like this:

Goldman, A. H. (1975). Reparations to individuals or groups?. Analysis, 35(5), 168-170.

Nickel, J. W. (1974). Should reparations be to individuals or to groups?. Analysis, 34(5), 154-160.

Sanderson, D. (2012). Redressing the Right Wrong: The Argument from Corrective Justice. University of Toronto Law Journal, 62(1), 93-132.

Thorne, D. (2016). How the Abigail Fisher case highlights difference between affirmative action in Canada and the U.S. TVO.org, July 22.

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered