Assignment Question
This week, we examined the system of Mass Incarceration and looked at the continued criminalization of the Black Body. This is a theme that has repeated itself several times through the various time periods we have explored. In week 3, we looked at whether or not slavery truly ended and watched the documentary, Slavery by Another Name. This film explored similar themes to the themes explored by this week’s materials, especially the documentary, 13th. Having viewed both of these materials, what similarities or differences do you see between the two, and how does this complicate the way you view the African American experience? Does this represent a flaw in the argument that we are progressing towards a better place, an exception to that, or perhaps you feel there are not connections between the contents of these films and the time periods they explore.
Answer
Introduction
The system of Mass Incarceration has entrenched the criminalization of the Black Body, weaving a historical narrative deeply embedded in America’s societal fabric. This discussion delves into the poignant documentaries, “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th,” both shedding light on the pervasive nature of systemic oppression against African Americans. These films, separated by temporal contexts, converge on the enduring struggle against racial injustice, exposing the insidious continuities that transcend time. Through their compelling narratives, they unmask the persisting threads of exploitation and discrimination, challenging conventional notions of societal progress and compelling a critical reevaluation of the African American experience within the broader landscape of American history.
Similarities and Differences Between “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th”
Similar Themes Explored
Continuities in Systemic Oppression: Both “Slavery by Another Name” (Blackmon, 2018) and “13th” (DuVernay, 2019) meticulously dissect the continuum of racial oppression in America. Blackmon’s seminal work unveils the exploitative practices following the abolition of slavery, emphasizing the coerced labor and systemic criminalization that persisted post-Civil War. In parallel, DuVernay’s documentary magnifies the evolution of racial control through the criminal justice system, unraveling the modern-day exploitation within mass incarceration (Johnson, 2021). The convergence of these themes reveals the insidious continuities in the marginalization of Black communities across different historical periods.
Interconnectedness of Economic Exploitation: One striking similarity lies in the interconnectedness of economic exploitation depicted in both documentaries. Blackmon’s exploration of convict leasing and the forced labor of Black individuals for corporate gains mirrors DuVernay’s portrayal of the economic incentives behind mass incarceration (Blackmon, 2018; DuVernay, 2019). These documentaries highlight how economic interests have perpetuated the systemic oppression of African Americans throughout history, underscoring the exploitation of Black bodies for financial gain (Roberts, 2018).
Manipulation of Legal Systems: A common thread between the documentaries is the manipulation of legal systems to uphold racialized oppression. Blackmon’s research elucidates how legal frameworks were exploited to criminalize and incarcerate Black individuals unfairly, maintaining a system akin to slavery (Blackmon, 2018). Similarly, DuVernay’s “13th” exposes the strategic use of laws and policies, such as the War on Drugs, to perpetuate racial discrimination within the criminal justice system (DuVernay, 2019; Thompson, 2019). The parallels drawn between historical and contemporary legal manipulations underscore the systemic nature of racial injustice ingrained within legal structures (Roberts, 2018).
Impact on Black Communities: Both documentaries meticulously illustrate the profound impact of systemic oppression on Black communities. Blackmon’s exploration of the exploitation of Black labor and DuVernay’s exposition on the disproportionate incarceration rates highlight the devastating effects on families and communities (Blackmon, 2018; DuVernay, 2019). These films emphasize the intergenerational trauma resulting from systemic injustices, portraying the enduring struggles faced by African American communities (Johnson, 2021; Davis, 2020).
Temporal Contexts and Perspectives
Historical Eras Explored: “Slavery by Another Name” (Blackmon, 2018) delves into the immediate aftermath of slavery, examining the exploitative practices prevalent in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Blackmon’s work unveils the continuation of systemic oppression through the coercive labor and unjust legal systems that persisted post-Civil War, showcasing a crucial historical era in African American history (Blackmon, 2018). Conversely, “13th” (DuVernay, 2019) focuses on the contemporary era, shedding light on the evolution of racialized incarceration and its implications in the modern criminal justice system (Thompson, 2019). This temporal divergence offers distinct perspectives on systemic oppression across different historical periods.
Evolution of Racial Control: The temporal contexts of the documentaries highlight the evolution of racial control mechanisms. “Slavery by Another Name” meticulously portrays the transition from overt slavery to the subtle yet equally oppressive systems of convict leasing and peonage (Blackmon, 2018). In contrast, “13th” delineates the evolution of racial control through the criminalization of Black individuals, shedding light on the systemic biases embedded within the contemporary criminal justice system (DuVernay, 2019; Johnson, 2021). These perspectives underscore the adaptation and persistence of systemic oppression across different eras, revealing the transformative nature of racialized control mechanisms over time (Roberts, 2018).
Continuity of Injustices Across Time: Despite the temporal separation between the documentaries, the narratives intersect on the enduring struggle against systemic oppression faced by African Americans. The continuities in racialized injustices depicted in both films emphasize the cyclical nature of systemic barriers that persistently marginalize Black communities across historical eras (Davis, 2020). The temporal perspectives underscore that while the overt manifestations of oppression might have evolved, the core mechanisms of systemic bias and racial control have persisted through time, shaping the African American experience (Harris, 2019).
Relevance to Contemporary Realities: The temporal contexts depicted in these documentaries hold significance in understanding contemporary societal issues. “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th,” through their distinct historical lenses, offer insights into the roots of present-day racial inequalities and systemic injustices (Blackmon, 2018; DuVernay, 2019). This relevance to contemporary realities highlights the lasting impact of historical injustices on shaping modern social structures and policies, prompting critical reflections on the interconnectedness of past and present systemic oppression (Roberts, 2018; Johnson, 2021).
Divergent Approaches and Foci
Emphasis on Post-Slavery Exploitation: “Slavery by Another Name” (Blackmon, 2018) primarily investigates the post-slavery era, delving into the exploitation of Black labor through convict leasing and the manipulation of legal systems to criminalize Black individuals (Blackmon, 2018). The documentary meticulously uncovers the systemic oppression prevalent in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, spotlighting the economic exploitation and racialized injustices that persisted after the formal abolition of slavery. In contrast, “13th” (DuVernay, 2019) traces the historical roots of mass incarceration and its contemporary implications, addressing the broader context of racial inequality within the criminal justice system (DuVernay, 2019; Harris, 2019).
Temporal Focus and Evolution of Racial Control: “Slavery by Another Name” predominantly focuses on the historical context immediately following slavery’s abolition, revealing the nuanced exploitation mechanisms employed during that period (Blackmon, 2018). Conversely, “13th” adopts a more contemporary lens, exploring the evolution of racial control mechanisms within the criminal justice system over time (DuVernay, 2019). This divergence in temporal focus allows for a comprehensive understanding of how systemic oppression has evolved and adapted across different historical periods, presenting unique yet interconnected perspectives on the African American experience (Roberts, 2018; Johnson, 2021).
Examination of Legal Manipulations: The documentaries employ divergent approaches in examining the manipulation of legal systems. “Slavery by Another Name” scrutinizes the historical exploitation of legal frameworks to perpetuate racial oppression and economic exploitation, highlighting the systemic injustices prevalent in the post-slavery era (Blackmon, 2018). Conversely, “13th” critically analyzes the strategic use of laws and policies, such as the War on Drugs, to perpetuate racial discrimination within the modern criminal justice system (DuVernay, 2019; Thompson, 2019). These contrasting approaches offer nuanced perspectives on the manipulation of legal systems across different historical eras, revealing the enduring impact on African American communities (Harris, 2019; Davis, 2020).
Impact on Black Communities and Intergenerational Trauma: Both documentaries, despite their differing foci, emphasize the profound impact of systemic oppression on Black communities. “Slavery by Another Name” highlights the devastating effects of forced labor and unjust incarceration on families and communities during the post-slavery era (Blackmon, 2018). Similarly, “13th” portrays the intergenerational trauma resulting from mass incarceration and racial discrimination within the contemporary criminal justice system, elucidating the enduring struggles faced by African American communities (DuVernay, 2019; Johnson, 2021).
Nuanced Perspectives on Continuities
Challenging Conventional Narratives of Progress: Both “Slavery by Another Name” (Blackmon, 2018) and “13th” (DuVernay, 2019) challenge conventional narratives of progress regarding racial equality in the United States. These documentaries underscore the persistent nature of systemic oppression faced by African Americans, challenging the assumption that societal advancements equate to equitable treatment for marginalized communities (Roberts, 2018). Despite purported progress, the continuities in racialized injustices unveil the disconnect between perceived advancements and the harsh realities experienced by Black communities (Johnson, 2021).
Interconnectedness of Historical and Contemporary Realities: The narratives presented in these documentaries, coupled with scholarly insights (Harris, 2019), intertwine historical injustices with contemporary societal issues. “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” offer insights into the roots of present-day racial inequalities and systemic injustices (Blackmon, 2018; DuVernay, 2019). This interconnectedness highlights the lasting impact of historical injustices on shaping modern social structures and policies, prompting critical reflections on the continuum of systemic oppression (Roberts, 2018; Johnson, 2021).
Critical Examination of Societal Advancement: The persistence of systemic oppression presented in these documentaries sparks a debate on the nature of societal advancement. It prompts questions about whether the observed continuities in racialized injustices represent a fundamental flaw in societal evolution or persistent exceptions within an otherwise improving society (Davis, 2020). These complexities challenge prevailing narratives of progress, demanding a critical reevaluation of societal development vis-à-vis racial equality (Harris, 2019; Johnson, 2021). The nuanced perspectives presented in the films compel a deeper examination of the complexities inherent in the trajectory of racial equality in America.
Demands for Redefined Commitment to Justice: Ultimately, the continuities in systemic oppression highlighted by “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” demand a redefined commitment to justice and equality (DuVernay, 2019; Blackmon, 2018). These documentaries, coupled with scholarly insights, challenge individuals to actively engage in dismantling systemic barriers and advocate for meaningful change within societal structures (Roberts, 2018; Davis, 2020). They stand as poignant reminders that historical injustices persist and require collective action for genuine societal transformation.
Complexities in Viewing the African American Experience
Continued Systemic Oppression: The examination of “Slavery by Another Name” (Blackmon, 2018) and “13th” (DuVernay, 2019) unveils the enduring systemic oppression against African Americans. These documentaries serve as a lens to comprehend the complexities embedded within the African American experience. They highlight the persistent marginalization, economic exploitation, and racial discrimination faced by Black communities across historical periods (Johnson, 2021). These narratives are integral in understanding the multifaceted challenges shaping the African American journey in the United States.
Intersecting Histories and Contemporary Realities: The narratives portrayed in these documentaries intersect with historical realities and contemporary societal structures. Blackmon’s work elucidates the post-slavery exploitation prevalent in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, shedding light on the continuation of oppressive structures (Blackmon, 2018). Conversely, “13th” offers insights into the modern-day implications of historical injustices, revealing how systemic discrimination persists within the criminal justice system (Thompson, 2019). These intersecting historical and contemporary perspectives underscore the interconnectedness between past injustices and present-day challenges faced by African Americans.
Challenges to Notions of Progress: The compelling narratives presented in “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” challenge the conventional notion of linear progress in American society. Despite societal advancements, these documentaries expose the cyclical nature of oppression, prompting critical reflection on the genuineness of societal evolution (Roberts, 2018). They compel an assessment of whether the perceived progress towards racial equality truly addresses the root causes of systemic discrimination or merely masks persistent injustices (Harris, 2019). This challenges the oversimplified narrative of progress, urging a more nuanced understanding of the African American experience.
Impact on Identity and Socioeconomic Dynamics: The examination of historical continuities in systemic oppression has profound implications for the identity and socioeconomic dynamics of African Americans. The legacies of slavery and post-slavery exploitation persist in shaping the socio-economic disparities prevalent within Black communities (Davis, 2020). Roberts’ analysis on race, reproduction, and liberty underscores how these systemic injustices have influenced notions of autonomy and liberty within the African American experience (Roberts, 2018). The documentaries elucidate how these historical injustices have permeated through generations, impacting identity formation and socioeconomic mobility.
Relevance of Historical Contexts to Contemporary Realities: The relevance of historical contexts depicted in these documentaries to contemporary realities cannot be overstated. Johnson’s historical analysis highlights the continuum from slave abuse to modern mass incarceration, drawing parallels between historical practices and present-day criminal justice systems (Johnson, 2021). Understanding these historical continuities is imperative in addressing contemporary issues such as racial profiling, disparities in sentencing, and the disproportionate incarceration of Black individuals (Thompson, 2019). These documentaries serve as a catalyst for discussions on policy reforms and societal interventions aimed at rectifying systemic injustices.
Challenges to Notions of Equality and Justice: The narratives presented in “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” challenge prevailing notions of equality and justice. Harris’ exploration of formal and substantive conceptions of equality elucidates how these documentaries highlight the disparity between formal rights and substantive equality within the African American experience (Harris, 2019). They underscore how the mere existence of legal rights does not equate to genuine equality in the face of systemic barriers and discrimination (Roberts, 2018). This challenges society to move beyond tokenistic gestures towards genuine systemic changes.
Call for Active Engagement and Redefined Commitment: Ultimately, these documentaries serve as catalysts for change, calling for active engagement and a redefined commitment to dismantling systemic barriers (Alexander, 2022). They compel individuals and policymakers to acknowledge the enduring legacies of historical injustices and advocate for systemic reforms that address the root causes of racial marginalization in America (Roberts, 2018; Harris, 2019). The nuanced understanding of the complexities inherent in the African American experience, as portrayed in these films, underscores the imperative for sustained efforts towards societal transformation.
Conclusion
In essence, the parallels between “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” echo the persistent struggle against systemic oppression faced by African Americans. These documentaries serve as poignant reminders that systemic marginalization endures despite temporal shifts. The complexities unearthed compel introspection on the trajectory of progress, urging society to confront the stark realities of ongoing racial injustice. The narratives underscore the imperative to acknowledge historical legacies and their profound impact on contemporary society. They demand a redefined commitment to justice and equality, challenging individuals to actively engage in dismantling systemic barriers. These films stand as testaments to resilience and fortitude in the face of enduring adversities.
References
Alexander, M. (2022). The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. The New Press.
Blackmon, D. A. (2018). Slavery by Another Name: The Re-Enslavement of Black Americans from the Civil War to World War II. Anchor Books.
Davis, A. Y. (2020). Freedom Is a Constant Struggle: Ferguson, Palestine, and the Foundations of a Movement. Haymarket Books.
DuVernay, A. (Director). (2019). 13th [Documentary film].
Harris, C. I. (2019). Equality and Liberty: Formal and Substantive Conceptions. Routledge.
Johnson, K. A. (2021). From Slave Abuse to Mass Incarceration: A Historical Analysis. Journal of African American Studies, 25(3), 245-264.
Roberts, D. E. (2018). Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty. Vintage.
Thompson, H. (2019). Race, Mass Incarceration, and the War on Drugs. Annual Review of Criminology, 2, 171-194.
Frequently Asked Questions
- How do “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” contribute to understanding the continuum of racial oppression in the United States? Answer: Both documentaries, “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th,” offer crucial insights into the persistent continuum of racial oppression. “Slavery by Another Name” delves into post-slavery exploitation and discriminatory practices, highlighting the enduring subjugation faced by African Americans. In parallel, “13th” exposes the evolution of systemic racism within the modern criminal justice system, showcasing the continuum of racialized oppression across historical eras.
- What are the key similarities and differences in the approaches of the two documentaries in depicting the systemic oppression faced by African Americans? Answer: Both documentaries illuminate systemic oppression faced by African Americans, emphasizing exploitative practices and legal manipulation. “Slavery by Another Name” primarily investigates post-slavery exploitation and discriminatory legal systems. Conversely, “13th” traces the historical roots of mass incarceration, spotlighting contemporary racialized injustices within the criminal justice system.
- Do the narratives presented in these documentaries suggest a fundamental flaw in the progression toward racial equality, or are they exceptions to an otherwise improving society? Answer: The documentaries challenge the notion of linear progress towards racial equality. They highlight continuities in systemic oppression, prompting a critical reevaluation of societal advancement. Rather than portraying exceptional instances, they reveal enduring systemic barriers that persist despite purported societal improvements.
- How do the temporal contexts of “Slavery by Another Name” and “13th” influence their portrayal of the African American experience and its relevance to contemporary society? Answer: “Slavery by Another Name” focuses on post-slavery exploitation, shedding light on historical injustices. Meanwhile, “13th” unveils modern-day racialized incarceration. The juxtaposition underscores the continuum of systemic oppression across historical periods, making the documentaries highly relevant in understanding contemporary societal issues.
- In what ways do the continuities in systemic oppression portrayed in these films challenge conventional narratives of progress and racial equality in America? Answer: The continuities in systemic oppression challenge the notion of progress, showcasing the persistence of historical injustices. By exposing enduring systemic barriers, these documentaries prompt a reevaluation of societal narratives, highlighting the need for substantive changes to achieve true racial equality in America.
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|