Enhanced Interrogation

Please respond provide a 250 word response to the post below discussing if they think that enhanced interrogation can be ethically justified. The post must contain direct questions. (post starts here) My initial knee jerk reaction from the readings this week was that “Enhanced Interrogations” (i.e., torture) cannot be ethically justified because of two main factors. The first being the thought of intentionally harming someone either physically or mentally while they are already detained and defenseless. This seems fairly unjustifiable, however, arguments could be presented about the treatment of inherently “evil” individuals but that begins another discussion of proving good vs evil as well as being above an adversary on moral and ethical standing. The second position pertains to the validity of information extracted from someone who may just want the pain to stop or may not be in the right state of mind to provide valuable information. Additionally, the social and cultural aspects could also be a factor in a person relinquishing information. Take for example a people that have had threat or actually dealt with foreign invaders in their countries for years and have been led to believe that they are monstrous people who want nothing more than to harm them. Torturing these people, even with justifiable torture, may further solidify their views and strengthen their resolve to either taint information or not relinquish it.
While I think in the generally case that it is difficult to ethically justify torture, there still may remain specific circumstances where it can be justified. Specifically when dealing with individuals who have “forfeited their natural rights to life, liberty, limb and property and where that person possesses information critical to safeguarding the lives of innocent people” (Tiel 2019, 39). The argument here stems from the killing in self-defense stance. If it is ethical to kill in self-defense, then the above case expands on that scenario to the protections of others by trying to extract information from an individual that seeks to willfully harm others.
Sources
Tiel, Jeffrey R. 2019. “Can Torture Be Justified?” Journal of Military Ethics 18:1, 35-47, DOI: 10.1080/15027570.2019.1627033

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered