case stusy: On 5 October, 2021, reforms under the Financial Sector Reform Act 2020 went into effect. These reforms included a prohibition on hawking financial products. According to the regulatory guide published by the Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC), the new prohibition says that a person must not, in the course of, or because of, an unsolicited contact with a retail client
offer financial products for issue or sale; or
request or inviting the client to ask or apply for financial products.
The maximum penalty for breaching the prohibition on hawking financial products is currently $13,320 and up to six months imprisonment for an individual or up to $133,200 for a body corporate. The consumer also has the right to return the product for a refund if the offeror breached the prohibition.
According to the ASIC regulatory guide, The objective of the prohibition is for consumers to have greater control over their decisions to purchase financial productsthe prohibition allows them to determine how they want to be contacted and the kinds of financial products they are offered.
The reforms were legislated in response to the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, also known as the Hayne Royal Commission. While previous law already contained certain prohibitions on hawking financial products, the Hayne Royal Commission found that the existing anti-hawking provisions do not effectively protect consumers from harm. Case studies showed widespread unsolicited sales of superannuation and insurance products and that hawking methods often contributed to consumers purchasing products that did not meet their needs (Financial Sector Reform (Hayne Royal Commission Response) Bill 2020, Explanatory memorandum, pg. 103). The Final Report of the Hayne Royal Commission notes that financial services companiesparticularly in regard to superannuation and insurance productswere able to take advantage of loopholes in the existing law and often used high-pressure sales techniques to sell financial products to unsuspecting consumers and provided inadequate descriptions of the products (e.g., section 4.1.2). Previous ASIC reports also noted that financial services companies used incentive schemes that encouraged sales staff and third party telemarketers to prioritise sales targets over the interests of consumers (Reports 587 and 622). The new law amended the corporations act to strengthen and broaden the existing hawking prohibition and implement recommendations 3.4 and 4.1 of the Final Report of the Hayne Royal Commission. Chapter 5 of the explanatory memorandum of the Financial Sector Reform Bill 2020 provides a summary of the changes to the law. Other sources that discuss the law change include:
Cold calls to hawk financial products outlawed, Sydney Morning Herald
ASIC Media Release 21-257MR: ASIC publishes guidance on hawking reforms
assignment: You are to conduct a case analysis of the case described above. Read the above case description and conduct further research as you deem it necessary. For example, you can use Factiva to search for other relevant articles. Note that you do not need to read the full legal documents and reports linked above. However, the relevant sections do contain useful insight into the rationale for the law change and the previous actions of financial services companies. Your written analysis of the case should focus on the decision of financial services companies about how to market their products to consumers. It should incorporate the most relevant information from the case description and your own research and address the following questions:
1. Who are the key stakeholders to the decision about whether to hawk financial products? Describe at least 4 and identify their needs and most important rights.
2. What were the key instrumental considerations for a financial services company about whether to hawk financial products before the recent law? How have these considerations changed? What key activities were legally permissible before that are now prohibited?
3. Consider the conditions for a market to be perfectly competitive and the conditions for the competitive market equilibrium to be economically efficient. Which of these conditions are most applicable and least applicable to the market for a financial product? Explain why financial services companies decisions about how to market their products to consumers might not lead to an economically efficient outcome.
4. What are the key normative considerations for a financial services company about whether to hawk financial products? Were these considerations affected by the law change?
5. As a manager of a financial services company, weighing both normative and instrumental considerations, would you have supported the law change? Why or why not?
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
