In 2004, the High Court handed down its decision in Cattanach v Melchior (2003) 215 CLR 1. (I have attached the FULL case “Cattanach v Melchior”)
Critically analyse how Justice Kirby arrived at his decision. (pages 40-73 in case document provided)
In your answer, include discussion of:
1. The role played by the application of legal authority to new circumstances
2. The application of relevant legal principles
3. Considerations of legal policy.
Where appropriate, support your analysis by comparing the selected judgment to that of other judgments in Cattanach v Melchior. Your answer should include a discussion of relevant case law and reference to relevant legal theories studied throughout the semester or referred to in the judgment.
I have provided the learning schedule for the semester where you can see which topics have been discussed throughout. Please use those topics and relate to Justice Kirby’s decision. Topics include: corrective justice, natural law, positivism, liberal theory, personal responsibility, law and economics.
Please use headings for the essay.
Distinction Average is required.
AGLC4 Referencing, and use 10 sources as a minimum.
Strong thesis, and link to corrective justice, pls include counter arguments and make sure all parts of the marking rubric is addressed.
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
