Plays pent

1. Then, go to:

http://playspent.org/ (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site.

2. Click on ‘Continue to Spent’

3. Play the ‘game’ – keep track of all of your answers (write them down, then list here)

4. When you are done, whether you make it through the month or not, write a paragraph or 2 about how it felt to go through this. Why/how/what determined your answers to some of the questions? Did you have an emotional response?

5. From the chapter in your text and the lecture notes for the week, add info from what you learned to your experience with Playspent. (1-2 solid paragraphs. cite.).

The most common critique of the activity is that some students feel too limited in the choices. Try not to let that get to you. The point of this is to get a sense of the many ‘choices’ people have to make each day.

Also, many of us have lived in poverty, or live in poverty right now. Living in poverty does not automatically lead someone to failure. It does, however, mean that in the stratified system we have, a person in poverty is going to have to work much harder to achieve social mobility (picture a ladder that signifies each social class – imagine being at the bottom of that ladder and how many more rungs one has to climb up than someone else higher up). And in a class where we focus on social problems it becomes even more clear how class and wealth inequality have a multitude of consequences.

Lecture notes

Social stratification

The arrangement of society into a series of layers or strata on the basis of an unequal distribution of societal resources, prestige, or power, such that the stratum at the top has the most resources.

Class vs Caste

Caste System

A fixed arrangement of strata with a persons position determined by birth.

India exemplifies a contemporary caste system, especially the rural areas.

Indian caste is changing due to : communication, transportation, industrialization, and the growth of the middle class.

Other historical examples of caste systems: Apartheid in South Africa, the American South under Jim Crow laws.

Class System

Social Standing is determined by factors over which people can exert some control.

Some mobility is possible.

Most people are status consistent have a similar ranking along the various dimensions of socioeconomic status

Socioeconomic status = a persons ranking along several social dimensions, particularly education, occupational prestige, and wealth/income.

Difference between wealth & income = wealth is assets, such as real estate and stocks; income = wages, salaries, interest received Inequalities based on social class

Lets begin by acknowledging that Americans do not have a very solid understanding of social class. The capitalist system that has developed since the European settlers is fairly new compared to other countries. In the U.S., we have not had the struggles between classes as seen around the world. Thus, our understanding of social class is limited to what we all know of as upper class, middle class, and lower class. If asked, most people say that they are middle class. Why? Think of your answer for a moment.

Most students tell me that a person would not want to admit that theyre upper class (or rich) for two reasons. First, they may not want others to think that they are snobby. Second, people may want something from them if they know that they are upper class.

The reasons for not admitting the one is lower class (or poor) is much more clear. Were all very aware of the stigma that is placed on poor people. Poor folk are often labeled as lazy, uneducated, unmotivated, unwilling to work. Who would want to be classified as such?

Thus, while the general population may not have a real sense of class positions and how to define each class, sociologists have developed ways to measure a persons social class. Following are 4 examples. Inequalities based on social class

Karl Marx – ones social class was solely determined by ones position in the economic system. Max Weber social class is defined by

Income – the money earned for ones work.

Wealth – the value of ones personal assets such as savings and property.

Prestige – the amount of social respect or standing given to an individual based on occupation.

Power – Weber defined power as the ability to achieve ones goals in spite of the opposition of others. Inequalities based on social class

C. Wright Mills – argued that the United States was ruled by a power elite composed of business, political and military leaders.

The power elite have true power because of their ability to withhold resources and prevent others from realizing their interests.

Richard Caputo – describes a condition of econosclerosis, the hardening of economic arteries, where increasing proportions of young adults are unable to do better than their parents economic status.

Inequalities based on social class

So how then do sociologists measure social class today?
Our model is close to that of Webers. We look at income, occupation, and education. Its not perfect, by any means, but we have found that there is a strong correlation between these 3.

In other words, if you have a high income its most likely that its because you have a prestigious occupation, and you got that prestigious occupation because you have a high level of education. I know, I know, I just asked you about questions on a previous slide about how teachers make less than professional athletes. If we were to use the formula above it would fail miserably. The person with a high level of education and fairly prestigious job (ie the teacher) is not guaranteed to make a high income in our society (anyone know what the average K-12 teacher makes their first year of teaching in California? Should I tell you? I really hate to when it may discourage those of you wanting to go into the profession..$30,000-$40,000 depending on the district. Sorry to be the one to tell you the news. But wait! Dont change your major yet. We REALLY need dedicated, educated, motivated people to teach our children. There are a lot of great things about teaching and money isnt everything, right???) Overall, the formula gives us a closer idea of how people fall on the social class ladder than anything else weve come up with.

Increasing gap between the rich and the poor

Now that you know how/what social class is, why do we talk about it so much today in Sociology? Well, the truth of the matter is that class inequality happens around the world, but what were seeing right now in the U.S. is the widest gap between the rich and the poor than in another other comparable society. The middle class is shrinking, and the resources available to the non-rich are shrinking as well. The most blatant, publicized example of this growing gap is CEO pay in the U.S. Im sure youve heard of some of the stories recently from our largest corporations. Exxon & Home Depot have made huge headlines. While some of you may be thinking, CEOs deserve huge salaries/bonuses/stock option, etc because they work hard and bring in profits for the companies, I cant necessarily argue with you there. Im sure they do work hard. But heres the reality. The average worker is having a really hard time making ends meet right now (well talk a lot about how the economy has changed). Housing costs, transportation costs, education costs have all increased while wages have not.

When we look at how much CEOs make compared to the average factory floor worker, heres what we see around the world:

In Japan, CEOs make 11 times what Japanese factory floor workers make

In Germany, CEOs make 12 times what German factory floor workers make

In France, 15 times

In Canada, 20 times

In Britain, 22 times

In Hong Kong, 41 times

In Mexico, 47 times

In Venezuela, CEOs make 50 times what Venezuelan factory floor workers make. Venezuela is the closest to what U.S. CEOs make compared to factory floor workers.

Whats your guess as to how much U.S. CEOs make compared to the average American factory floor worker?

Cmon, venture a guess. Over 350!!

(Source: The Economist)

Thats not a typo, I promise. In the U.S., the average CEO salary is over 350 times the salary of an American factory floor worker. This is what we mean by income inequality. The results of income inequality are that life opportunities and chances change depending on what social class you live at. Why might we view this as a problem? Well, American workers are struggling. The middle class is shrinking as more people fall into the lower classes. 1% of Americans own 80% of the wealth. While you might think that American CEOs deserve to make the money that they do, right now people are starting to ask: How much do they really need? Research this more, expect to be shocked (ie. A $30,000 monthly car allowance for a CEO as part of his retirement package)

The Myth and Reality of Mobility in the U.S.

Intergenerational Mobility

Standing of children compared to standing of their parents. This may be the hardest thing for you to take in this class, but the reality for generations born after the baby boomers (1945-1963) is that we are NOT doing better than our parents. In other words, past generations have been able to become better educated than their parents, attain more wealth than their parents, and move up the social ladder. Due to structural conditions, current generations are not able to do the same. Right now, most people in the U.S. remain in the social class in which they were born. Social mobility is not as possible as we are led to believe (the whole American dream thing, right?) Now, do not drop this class and tell your family that theres no reason for you to go to school because social mobility is not possible. The ONE thing that enables people to move up the social ladder is education.

Determinants of mobility

1. Lack of room at the top

2. Starting position on the socioeconomic ladder

3. Structural mobility = the movement of entire categories of people caused by changes in society itself

Defining and measuring poverty

Poverty is loosely defined as lacking resources for an adequate standard or living

-Absolute poverty characterized by the lack of basic necessities of life (food, clean water, housing)

-Relative poverty having a deficiency in material and economic resources compared with some other population

These are important distinctions to make, because I hear all the time from students that at least poor people have it better here than in other parts of the world. While that may be true, do we have people living in relative poverty here in the U.S.? Absolutely. I would also argue that we have people living in absolute poverty as well, as evidenced by research in both big cities and rural areas

Multidimensional aspects of poverty

Poverty is multidimensional and includes such dimensions as:

Food insecurity = limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods or limited or uncertain ability to acquire acceptable foods in socially acceptable ways

Poor housing

Unemployment/underemployment

Psychological distress

Powerlessness

Hopelessness

Lack of access to health care, education, and transportation

Vulnerability

High infant mortality and childhood deaths

Lower life expectancies among adults

An Example

Heres an example of the multidimensional aspects of poverty:

If you know anything about Native Americans living on reservations in the U.S. right now, this will not surprise you (if you dont know, please take some time to learn about this reality). Due to many structural factors, Native Americans suffer from high rates of diseases like tuberculosis and diabetes, high rates of alcoholism, high rates of unemployment, and extreme poverty.

On the Red Lake Reservation in Minnesota, the average life expectancy is 47 years. This statistic saddens me every time I think about it. Whats the average life expectancy in the U.S. in general? In the mid-upper 70s. The fact that we have a group of people living in the U.S. with such significant differences in quality and quantity of life is not general knowledge. Why not? I wish I had the answer.

We have amazing technology, an over-abundance of food (the govt pays some farmers NOT to grow crops because we have so much), the ability to educate millions of children, extremely valuable natural resources wherever we turn, and yet not everyone has equal access to these things. Thats the reality of living in poverty in the U.S.

U.S. Measure of poverty

2021 Federal Poverty line = $26,500/year for a family of four (thats before taxes by the way, which means that the actual cash coming in to the family would be significantly less).

U.S. poverty line was originally based on idea that families with 3 or more members spend one-third of their income on food, so poverty line was set at 3 times the minimum cost of an adequate diet

3 Criticisms of Federal Poverty Line

-Due to rising costs of housing, medical care, and child care, low-income families spend one-tenth (rather than one-third) of income on food, so poverty line should be based on multiplying food costs by 10 rather than 3

-Does not account for taxes that affect amount of income available to families

-Disregards regional differences in cost of living (FPL for Alaska and Hawaii is a little higher, but the rest is the same). In other words, the line does not change whether you live in the Bay Area or Arkansas. This is problematic, obviously, as we all know that the cost of living is significantly different depending on where we are in the U.S.

Welfare in the U.S.:

Myths and Realities

Myth: People receiving welfare are lazy and have no work ethic
Reality: Single parents do the work of parenting, Most adults on public assistance are either employed or looking for work
ALSO: Have you ever considered this: Women on welfare on demonized for staying home to watch the kids; women who work are demonized for not staying home to watch the kids..hmmm..

Myth: Welfare benefits are granted to many people who are not really eligible to receive them
Reality: Some obtain through fraudulent means, but it is much more common for people who are eligible to receive welfare to not receive benefits (eg at least 12 million people are not receiving food stamps even though they are eligible). Reasons for not receiving benefits include: people dont know they are eligible, pride: people do not want to be stigmatized, transportation issues
Myth: Most welfare parents are teenagers
Reality: The average age of adult welfare recipients is 31.8 years. Only 6% are teenagers.
Myth: Most welfare mothers have large families with many children
Reality: Mothers receiving welfare have no more children, on average, than mothers in the general population (Average = 2)
Myth: Unmarried women have children so they can receive benefits and single mothers receiving welfare have additional children in order to receive increased benefits
Reality: States with lowest welfare benefits to single mothers have highest birthrates Myth: Public assistance to the poor creates an enormous burden on taxpayers
Reality: Public assistance to the poor is small part of government spending (3%)
Why do these myths persist?
Poor folks, especially poor single mothers, are a handy scapegoat. Most social problems are blamed on them. This serves the elite very well with the focus on a segment of the population that does not have many resources to fight back, myths continue on. And when families face the multi-dimensional aspects of poverty, their strategies revolve around survival, not debunking myths about them.

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered