Background:
When a Dodgers fan goes to a Dodger’s game, we assume this fan acted freely because the action is consistent with the fan’s identity.
It’s what a Dodgers fan fan does.
This doesn’t seem controversial, but this type of reasoning can make people vulnerable to coercion.
Heres how:
If we want someone who is not a Dodger’s fan to go to a Dodger’s game, we dont have to kidnap them we just need to make them into a Dodger’s fan. If you succeed in imposing an identity, then you make identity-based actions appear to be freely chosen. They appear to be freely chosen because the coercive force conditions their WANTS.
This is an (awkward) analogy to MacKinnons reasoning about prostitution.
She argues that Sex in general, particularly sex for survival, is so pervasively merged with the meaning of being a woman that whenever sex occurs, under whatever conditions, the woman tends to be defined as freely acting.
In other words, it only appears that women in sex work are acting freely because their choices are consistent with an identity. In a sexist system, what it means to be a woman is to be sexually disposable. As we saw in the Dodger’s example, forcefully imposing an identity can make identity-based actions appear free.
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
